What about a personalised "Pin the... on the ...." game.

Pin the tail on the donkey is now old hat but what about

• pin the glasses on granpa (larger than life picture of your very own granpa!)
  
• pin the nose on the clown
• pin the puppy on Paris
  
• pin the hat on the witch
  
• pin the emblem on a super hero
  
• pin the skull on the skeleton
  
• pin the sausage on the BBQ
  
• pin the cherry on the cupcake
  
• pin the honey pot on the bear
• pn the horn on the unicorn
  
• or choose your own design idea.....